Valuation - Direct Comparison Method

Question 
using a direct comparison method, ascertain a market value of a leasehold interest in a condominium unit located on the 5th floor of 12 storey condominium block known as A0505, Block A, Estana Court, Jalan Haji Mokhtar, Kampung Pasir, Hulu Kelang, Ampang, Selangor. The unit has a floor area of 74.32 square meter. Its currently unoccupied.

1 square meter = 10.7639 square feet
74.32 x 10.7639 = 800 square feet





 Property 1
 Property 2
 Property 3
 Subject Property

Leasehold
Block A
Unit A0417
Level 4
800 sf
3 Room
2 Bath
RM 230k
28th Nov 2016
normal transaction
normal unit
middle floor
non bumi
vacant - ?

Leasehold
Block A
Unit A1201
Level 12 
1,615 sf
5+1 Room
? Bath
RM 240k
9th March 2017
normal transaction
duplex
high floor
non bumi
vacant - ?


Leasehold
Block A
Unit A0104
Level 1 
800 sf
3 Room
2 Bath
RM 95,600
13th June 2012
auction transaction
normal unit
low floor
bumi
vacant - ?


Leasehold
Block A
Unit A0505
Level 5
800 sf
3 Room
2 Bath
RM?
?
normal transaction
normal unit
middle floor
non bumi
vacant - yes


i) Given that the property price differences between levels 1% and -1%. Analyses the sale comparable tabulated above and make necessary adjustment. State justification of your analysis.

using the analysis in i) calculate the market value of the condominium unit for financing purpose

Answer

 we assume the building cost is RM 121





RM 230k
800sf

Building Cost
RM 121 x 800
= 96,800

Land Value
RM 230k - RM 96,800
= RM 96,570

RM 240k
1,615 sf


RM 121 x 1615
= 195,415 


RM240k- RM 195,415
= RM 44,585
RM 95,600
800sf


RM 121 x 800
= 96,800

RM 230k - RM 96,800
= RM 96,570
?
800sf


RM 121 x 800
= 96,800
 

Base on the information given above. Adjust the
a) percentage
b) new land value persf











 

Base on the information given above.

Land Value Persf = RM 276 per sf
Total Land Area = Standard Area + Extra Land Area
3038 sf  = 1650 sf + 1388 sf

Building Cost = RM 121 per sf
Total Build Up = Floor Area + Ancillary Area
2100 sf = 1780 sf + 320 sf 

Find out the
a) Land Value
b) Building Cost
c) Property Value